Doing things in-house and on your own often appears as the more lucrative choice, saving ample resources—both labor and money. But when it comes to filing customs for importers, the decision becomes significantly tougher.

On one hand, there is the allure of direct control and potential cost savings. On the other, the daunting complexities of customs regulations loom, threatening to ensnare the unwary with costly penalties and delays.

So, what is the right move in such a scenario?

This blog will help you make this decision. We will discuss the advantages and pitfalls and determine which optimizes your business’s resources. Let’s get started.

Advantages and Pitfalls Of Self-Filing

When considering whether to handle customs filings in-house or rely on the services of a customs broker, it is essential to weigh the benefits and drawbacks of each approach.

Let’s first look at the advantages of self-filing vs not filing an entry yourself.

Advantages of Entry Self-Filing
Advantages of Not Self-Filing an Entry
Cost Savings: Potentially lower operational costs over time compared to broker fees.
Expertise on Demand: Access to brokers with specialized knowledge and experience in customs clearance.
Direct Control: Greater oversight and immediate control over the customs filing process.
Resource Savings: Saves time and resources by outsourcing complex customs processes to experts.
Faster Response: Ability to quickly address and resolve issues or make adjustments as needed.
Reduced Liability: Brokers often assume responsibility for errors, reducing the company's risk exposure.
In-depth Knowledge: Opportunity to develop a deeper understanding of customs regulations and compliance requirements.
Broad Network: Brokers have established relationships with customs and other entities, potentially smoothing the process.
Customized Solutions: Flexibility to tailor customs filing processes to specific business needs.
Technology and Infrastructure: Brokers provide the necessary technology and infrastructure for efficient filing with no extra cost to the company.

Now, let us compare the pitfalls associated with self-filing versus outsourcing this task to professionals.

Pitfalls of Self-Filing
Pitfalls of Not Self-Filing
Initial Setup Costs: Significant upfront investment in technology, training, and staffing.
Higher Long-term Costs: Broker fees can add up over time, potentially exceeding the cost of in-house processing.
Compliance Risks: Increased responsibility for maintaining compliance, with the potential for costly mistakes.
Less Control: Reliance on external parties may reduce direct control over the customs clearance process.
Resource Intensity: Requires dedicated staff and resources to manage the filing process effectively.
Possible Delays: Dependence on a broker's schedule can lead to delays in filing and processing.
Learning Curve: There is a steep learning curve for businesses new to customs regulations and processes.
Generic Solutions: Brokers' processes may not be tailored to the specific needs of your business.
Technology Management: Need to update and maintain IT infrastructure for customs connectivity constantly.
Communication Barriers: Potential for miscommunication or delays in information flow between the business and the broker.

10 Questions To Ask Before Coming To A Conclusion About Self-Filing

Before diving into the crucial questions that can guide your decision on whether to transition customs filing in-house, it is essential to understand the implications of such a move.

This checklist spotlights the critical areas of consideration, ensuring you are fully informed and prepared to make the best choice for your business’s unique needs.

Let’s explore what you need to assess.

1. How Much Will In-House Filing Cost You?

The first thing to consider here is the finances. Hiring someone in-house, especially a licensed broker, is not just about their salary. You must consider benefits, training, and maybe even a support team. 

Now, consider what you paid your brokerage last year. Comparing these figures will help you understand the value of the expertise you are getting.

Winner: Outsource

Remember, while saving money sounds excellent, ensuring compliance without hiccups or delays can save you much more in the long run.

2. Who's Your Go-To for Regulatory Insight?

When it comes to customs clearance, having a reliable source for regulatory guidance is crucial.

If you are selected for a Customs Audit or need to confirm if a new regulation affects you, can you depend on your in-house team?

Partnering with experts like CustomsCity becomes invaluable here. They bring over 30 years of experience and expertise to your team, ensuring you stay ahead of regulatory changes.

Winner: It’s a tie

While outsourcing can offer unparalleled expertise and peace of mind, a well-trained and experienced in-house team could potentially offer similar benefits, assuming you are prepared to invest in their ongoing education and development.

3. Are You Prepared to Manage the Electronic Data Transmission

Brokers provide smooth connectivity with customs via ABI and ACE. If you are considering managing this in-house, assess whether your IT resources are ready for such a responsibility.

Partnering with experts like CustomsCity provides the necessary technical expertise and offers a streamlined process that could free up your IT budget and resources for other projects.

Winner: Outsource

The complexity and ongoing nature of IT requirements for direct filing can be daunting. Outsourcing can alleviate these pressures and ensure you remain compliant with minimal hassle.

4. What's Your Plan for Coverage Gaps?

Consider what happens if your sole filer is unavailable. Brokerage teams ensure there is always someone ready to step in. But can you say the same for your in-house team? Having a reliable backup plan is crucial to prevent any filing delays or issues.

Winner: Outsource

The risk of coverage gaps with an in-house team—especially if relying on a small team or single individual—can lead to significant disruptions. Outsourcing provides a safety net that is hard to replicate internally without significant investment.

5. Are You Ready to Scale Up With Your Importing Needs?

As your business grows, so will your volume of imports. A skilled broker seamlessly adjusts to these changes, ensuring your operations never miss a beat. But can your in-house team handle fluctuating volumes with the same agility?

Winner: It’s a tie

If you have built a robust, scalable, and flexible in-house team, you might manage just as well as an external broker. However, the ease and efficiency offered by a seasoned broker who is used to handling volume changes require a lot of work to match.

6. Can Your Team Efficiently Communicate With Logistics Partners?

Effective communication with carriers and warehouses is essential but time-consuming. Brokers leverage electronic connections to automate much of this process.

Is your team prepared to invest significant time in these communications, or do you have a system to streamline them?

Winner: Outsource

Unless you have the infrastructure to automate communications similarly, a broker’s established systems offer a clear advantage in time and efficiency.

7. How Will You Ensure Your Shipments Are Tracked and Delivered On Time?

Brokers track your shipments, ensuring they arrive and are delivered punctually, often without additional fees. If you consider managing this in-house, do you have the resources and dedication to match this level of service?

Winner: Outsource

The meticulous attention and time commitment required to effectively track and trace shipments can be overwhelming for many in-house teams. This makes a broker’s comprehensive service a more reliable option.

8. How Prepared Are You to Handle the Complexities of Special Imports?

Handling special imports, such as those subject to anti-dumping duties or quotas, demands detailed knowledge and precise documentation. Are you confident in your in-house team’s ability to manage these complexities smoothly?

Winner: It’s a tie

With the right training and resources, an in-house team could competently handle special entries. However, the specialized expertise of a broker often makes them better equipped to navigate these challenges with fewer risks of errors or delays.

9. Can You Coordinate Cargo Pickup and Delivery Without a Hitch?

Brokers excel in coordinating the many moving parts involved in cargo release, pickup, and delivery, ensuring smooth operations even when customs exams are required. Does your in-house operation have the capability to manage these logistics seamlessly?

Winner: Outsource to a broker

The logistical coordination required for effective pickup and delivery is complex, especially under the pressure of customs exams. Brokers have the experience and systems in place to handle these situations more efficiently than most in-house teams.

10. Do You Have the Industry Connections to Solve Issues Quickly?

The relationships experienced brokers have built over the years in the industry can significantly expedite processes and resolve issues. Does your in-house team have access to a similarly influential network?

Winner: Outsource to a broker

While it is possible to build relationships over time, the immediate access to a broad network of industry contacts brokers provide is invaluable, particularly when time-sensitive issues arise.

In Conclusion

The decision to self-file or outsource customs clearance is nuanced and dependent on your business’s specific needs, capabilities, and resources. If you are leaning towards outsourcing, consider partners like CustomsCity for their deep expertise and technological solutions.

For those pondering an in-house approach, assess your readiness across technology, knowledge, and resource scalability. Your next step should be a thorough analysis of your current operations, costs, and long-term business strategy to determine the most effective path forward for your customs clearance needs, keeping compliance, efficiency, and scalability at the forefront of your decision-making process.

Book a Free Consultation Today

Recent Blogs

Stay Connected

Get Customs City news
delivered to your
inbox.

NEWSLETTER